Burkean Advice for New Majorities

I tell lawmakers some version of this when it comes to making election policy. With massive legislative turnover across America, it will apply in January from sea to shining sea.
Burkean Advice for New Majorities
A sign at the March for Our Democracy rally in Manhattan the Saturday after Election Day, carrying a message our contributor advises against. (AP Photo/Lyndsey Regis)

The blue tsunami that swept across the country earlier this month has brought many newly elected, and understandably excited, Democrats to positions of power. As they prepare to govern, I’d like to offer some unsolicited advice. Not a warning, exactly. More like words of caution from someone who has spent decades watching how legislating actually works.

Study first. Move deliberately. Act justly. Be humble.

This is advice I give most especially in the arena of election law. The inclination of most new majorities is that “I want 100% of what I want, and I want it now,” as they channel Veruca Salt in Willy Wonka & the Chocolate Factory. But let me quote someone who asked instead for patience, not the whole world, in governing and policymaking in general:

“A disposition to preserve, and an ability to improve, taken together, would be my standard of a statesman.” 

And:

“By a slow but well-sustained progress, the effect of each step is watched; the good or ill success of the first, gives light to us in the second.”

Edmund Burke wrote these words nearly 250 years ago, about a revolution that was a bit more overwhelming than the one we saw here the first week of November. Their value continues today.

Some of the loudest voices among new legislative majorities will want to rip out all election law passed by Republicans root and branch. They will want to replace it with an idealized election system. That, my friends … is impossible. Such a system cannot exist because human beings are the most important, yet most fallible part of it.

I fully understand that recent election law changes in certain states were justified by false claims about widespread fraud and systemic insecurity. But bad arguments for legislation do not automatically make every provision of that legislation bad policy. Consider the perspective of the voters. Most of us now agree that the states run very secure elections, and very well. An Ipsos poll taken after Election Day finds that 68 percent of Americans are confident the Midterms were conducted fairly and accurately, including 92 percent of Democrats.

To go in for wholesale change would be foolish and counter-productive — just as many Republican-led legislatures have tried and failed to do this decade, such as in Wyoming. It would expend valuable political capital on an issue that a clear majority of Americans feel is settled. Current election systems are the ones under which each of November’s winners were just elected. Those winners shouldn’t go into office with score-settling in mind.

As I wrote above, there is a rubric for approaching these issues, and I’ll state it directly as if I were talking in person:

First, study. Don’t rely solely on your campaign talking points. Those were for winning. Now you have the responsibility of governing. When working in election law and administration, the people to put first are the voters. The people to listen to are not the activists — of either party — but to the county or municipal employees who actually run the elections every year … day by day. They know what works and what doesn’t. They have been operating within the current legal and administrative structures. They have been succeeding within them. Trust that they know what they are doing and will want to put the voters first. There, your interests align.

Second, move deliberately. Your supporters, and maybe even you, will want to move at warp speed to bring changes. As I noted in quoting Burke, moving slowly will yield the best results. Moving deliberately will allow those on the ground, the localities that run the elections and the state infrastructure that supports them, to digest, train, and prepare. Wholesale changes will lead to failures. Those failures will be exploited by those who wish to undermine the performance and trust of our shared institutions.

In Georgia, I’ve seen firsthand what it takes to implement major election changes across 159 counties. Just a sentence added to a statute can mean months of work for county election directors, new training for thousands of poll workers, changes to technology, revised procedures, and new instructions for voters. Be mindful that a legislature can pass a law in a day, but making that law work can take a year.

Third, act justly. There is a dark part of human nature: that part which feeds the “victor over vanquished” feeling that tempts the winners. This is especially so when the winner has been shut out for a longer period of time, or the vanquished acted particularly unjustly when they were in power. To achieve long-term acceptance of potential changes, you must act justly to allow for acceptance. Don’t make changes you think may give you an electoral advantage. We have all seen how voters respond to that.

Fourth, be humble. This may be the most important. As much as each of us may believe that our policy preferences will solve all of society’s ills, we are all wrong. By that I mean societies and institutions comprise flawed, imperfect humans who are all made in the image of God and fall woefully short. Your idea may be good, it may be great; yet it may also merit further reflection, invite legitimate and good-faith challenges, and turn out not so wonderful after all once scrutinized. And implementation, adoption, and long-term demands all stress and strain even great ideas. This is not an argument against legislating. It’s an argument against searching for silver bullets and convincing yourself you’ve found one.

Where there are obvious barriers to registration or voting, by all means, remove them wisely. My advice is to follow what many in the election community have already adopted: a culture of consistent, steady improvement. For you, that means carefully examining processes, training, and technology, and, where applicable, the existing laws they come from. As I have said when I have spoken around the country: If you are not measuring, and you are not investing in improvements, you are failing your voters.

I lay out these bits of advice in the arena of election law and administration. Of course, the advice holds in all areas. I have spent 40-plus years in and around politics and government. It is the odd day for a decisionmaker to have an obvious right choice and an obvious wrong one. More often it comes down to a not-great choice and a slightly worse choice. Most often, governing is about trade-offs.